How to evaluate voting guides

How to Evaluate Voting Guides – May Matters Texas
Voting Made Simple

How to Evaluate Voting Guides

Every election season, voting guides flood your inbox, your feed, and your group chats. That's especially true in a runoff, when information is thinner and stakes are just as high. Guides can be genuinely useful. But not all of them are built the same way, and knowing the difference takes about two minutes.

What a voting guide is (and isn't)

A good voting guide helps you understand:

  • Who's on your ballot — candidates, judges, local offices
  • What ballot measures and constitutional amendments mean
  • Key dates and rules for voting in your county

A voter education resource is designed to be nonpartisan and fact-based — it aggregates candidate responses without advocating for any outcome. Not every guide works that way. Part of being an informed voter is knowing where a guide is coming from and why it exists.

Red Flags Watch for these.
🚩
Overt endorsements

If a guide mixes candidate information with explicit support for a candidate, party, or position on an issue, that's advocacy. Not education.

🚩
Loaded language

Words like "radical," "dangerous," or "heroic" tell you how to feel rather than what's true. Persuasion language is a sign the guide has a goal beyond informing you.

🚩
No source transparency

If the guide doesn't clearly say who published it, what their mission is, and how they gathered the information, you have no way to evaluate what you're reading.

🚩
Missing candidates or issues

If some candidates' answers appear and others don't, or only certain sides of an issue get covered, the guide is shaping your understanding — not informing it.


Green Flags Look for these.
Equal treatment of all candidates

Trustworthy guides include responses from every relevant candidate and don't leave voices out to nudge you toward a particular outcome.

Sourced citations

High-quality guides link to original statements, candidate websites, official sample ballots, or public records so you can verify the details yourself.

Clear about who made it and why

Good guides tell you exactly who published them, what their mission is, and what methodology they used to collect candidate information.

Facts and context without a verdict

The best guides explain what each office does and why it affects your community. They give you the information to decide for yourself — not the decision.


Three quick tips

How to use guides well.

Cross-check what you read

No single guide tells the whole story. Compare sources from civic nonprofits, trusted local media, and official state resources like the Texas Secretary of State's sample ballots.

Go back to the original

If a guide summarizes a candidate's position, find the original response or their website. Summaries can compress meaning in ways that change it.

Use official tools too

Official sample ballots from VoteTexas.gov confirm who's actually on your ballot and what races are in play. No editorializing. Just the facts.

Voting guides are tools, not verdicts. The best ones help you understand the offices, candidates, and issues so you can make the call that reflects your own values. Taking two minutes to evaluate a source makes your voice stronger at the ballot box.

Questions? We're here.

Contact Us